Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups

4.3 stars, average of 66 ratings

Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate CupsPin recipeFollow us 123.7k

I’ve always been a fan of Reese's chocolate peanut butter cups… just not the ingredient list that goes along with them! This low-carb version is far healthier and is devoid of any nastiest included in the original, without compromising on taste.

A note on the chocolate — I like these best with a really dark chocolate like Lindt 90%, however they’re closer to the original if you can find a good keto-friendly milk chocolate. Either use this in place of the dark chocolate, or use half dark/half milk.

I love these cups finished with a sprinkle of sea salt — not entirely conventional, but the subtle bursts of saltiness combined with the sweet, creamy chocolate and nut butter go together amazingly. If you do add the sea salt make sure you add it after the chocolate has set, otherwise it will melt into the chocolate.

Hands-on Overall

Nutritional values (per cup)

Net carbs1.7 grams
Protein1.7 grams
Fat7.9 grams
Calories81 kcal

Calories from carbs 8%, protein 8%, fat 84%

Total carbs2.6 gramsFiber0.9 gramsSugars0.8 gramsSaturated fat2.8 gramsSodium2 mg(0% RDA)Magnesium30 mg(8% RDA)Potassium87 mg(4% EMR)

Ingredients (makes 12 cups)

Note: You can use peanut butter if you can tolerate legumes. Can't eat nuts? Try toasted coconut butter or sunbutter.

Instructions

  1. Mix the nut butter and erythritol together in a small bowl, and place in the freezer for at least 10–15 minutes to harden (do not use granulated sweetener or the cups will be gritty).
    Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  2. In the meantime, prepare the chocolate by roughly chopping it, and melt it over a very low heat on the stove, stirring constantly. If it appears to be getting too hot, remove from the heat and keep stirring – the chocolate will continue to melt.
    Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  3. Once all of the chocolate has melted, place about a teaspoon full into the bottom of each mould, and use teaspoon to coat the sides of the mould with the chocolate (alternatively you could use a pastry brush to do this). This should use roughly half the chocolate. Set the rest aside, and place the moulds in the freezer to harden.
    Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  4. Remove the nut butter mix, and roll into small marble-sized pieces. Remove the moulds from the freezer, and place a nut butter ball in the centre of each, on top of the hardened chocolate.
  5. Pour the remaining chocolate evenly over the top of each to fill each mould. Note that you may need to heat up the remaining chocolate if it has started to set to ensure it pours easily.
    Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  6. Place the moulds in the freezer or fridge to set. Once set, sprinkle with sea salt flakes (can be skipped but is highly recommended!). Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  7. Store in the fridge in a sealed container for up to one month. One serving (cup) is about 15 grams (0.5 oz). Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups

Ingredient nutritional breakdown (per cup)

Net carbsProteinFatCalories
Extra dark chocolate, 90% cocoa (cacao)
1.1 g0.8 g4.7 g47 kcal
Almond & cashew butter
0.5 g0.9 g3.2 g33 kcal
Erythritol (natural low-carb sweetener)
0.1 g0 g0 g0 kcal
Total per cup
1.7 g1.7 g7.9 g81 kcal
  1. Blog
  2. Recipes
  3. Desserts
  4. Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  1. Blog
  2. Recipes
  3. Vegan
  4. Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  1. Blog
  2. Recipes
  3. Vegetarian
  4. Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  1. Blog
  2. Recipes
  3. Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
  1. Blog
  2. Dearna Bond
  3. Healthy "Peanut" Butter Chocolate Cups
Download Recipe

Do you like this recipe? Share it with your friends! 

Dearna Bond
Creator of ToHerCore.com

Dearna Bond

Dearna is a passionate foodie and food photographer, and loves sharing her knowledge and enthusiasm for both via her food blog and online photography courses.

Let us know what you think, rate this recipe!

Leave a comment

Note: Any links to products or affiliate links will not be approved.
Please note that we do not offer personalised advice. For any diet related questions, please join our Facebook community.

Comments (5)

Hello Martina!  Your sweets look amazing.  I'm curious how you figure out the Ingredient nutritional breakdown for the recipes?  Is there a website that you use?
Thanks and I look forward to hearing back from you!! Terri.

Reply

Thank you Terri! All nutrition facts are calculated with our KetoDiet App and they are always shared via the app too. You can actually add them to your Planner directly via the KetoDiet Blog section in our app: ketodietapp.com/
More about our food database and why it's more accurate than other apps: Barcode Scanning and Food Database in the KetoDiet App

Reply

Thank you very much for the information!  

Reply

Hello! I absolutely adore these peanut butter cups since Reece’s is the only “cheap” chocolate I really miss! I would really appreciate it if you could add to the recipe, the serving size. Is it 2 cups (like Reece’s) or just 1? Also, I always wind up using two bars of Lindt or Ghiradelli 86% cocoa, not just one, but I get 16 cups instead of 12. Perhaps you could add the weight of a serving? I am sticking to a very strict Keto diet formula and I record everything I eat in my app (just until I reach my goal weight!)
I also have one tip for other people like me who want a more peanutty taste but are staying away from peanut butter.  I add 2-3 tablespoons of toasted sesame oil with just 1T of almond. It makes the flavor just a bit more peanutty! Thank you again!!!

Reply

Hi Marianna, thank you for your feedback! I will add more info now, it is only 1 cup/serving.

Reply