Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies

Spooky Eyeball Keto CookiesPin recipeFollow us 50.2k

These spooky eyeball keto cookies are the perfect grain-free and sugar-free treat for Halloween. Although they do take a little more effort, they are totally worth it.

I used my 5-Ingredient Keto Cookies for the base. Once they were baked and chilled, I topped them with a simple raspberry chia jam (adapted from my Quick Keto Book), vanilla & cinnamon flavoured mascarpone cheese, and finally topped them with pumpkin seed butter and black tahini paste.

While the chia jam created a bloody eye effect, the green pumpkin seed butter and black tahini paste created the spooky eyes. I prefer my treats not too sweet, so I only used a small amount of powdered Erythritol in the cookie dough. If you prefer more sweetener, feel free to add some into the chia jam and mascarpone layer.

Lastly, I have to warn you - these cookies are addictive! They should keep in the fridge for up to 5 days but I doubt they will last for more than a couple of days :-) I hope you like them - let me know in the comments!

Looking for a spooky savoury treat? Try my Halloween Keto Pizza or Cheesy Keto Spinach Crackers, and even more Halloween Keto Recipes.


Nutritional values (per cookie)

2.8 grams 4.4 grams 6.2 grams 19.5 grams 6.8 grams 240 calories
Total Carbs7.2grams
Net Carbs2.8grams
of which Saturated6.8grams
Magnesium71mg (18% RDA)
Potassium214mg (11% EMR)

Macronutrient ratio: Calories from carbs (5%), protein (12%), fat (83%)

Ingredients (makes 12 cookies)

Raspberry Chia Jam:
Mascarpone Layer:
Eye Decoration:

Tip: You can use roasted pumpkin or pistachio butter but it won't be green like raw butter. These cookies can easily be converted into a 4th of July treat! Simply use blueberries in place of the pumpkin seed butter and tahini!


  1. Prepare the raspberry chia jam. Place the raspberries in a small saucepan and mash using a fork. Add the water. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  2. Bring to a boil over medium heat and cook for 2 to 3 minutes to soften, then remove from the heat. Optionally, add the stevia. Finally, add the chia seeds. Stir and let the mixture sit for at least 20 minutes to thicken and cool. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  3. Store in the fridge in a jar or an airtight container until ready to be used, or for up to 1 week. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  4. To make the cookies, preheat the oven to 160 C / 320 F. Place all the ingredients in a food processor and pulse until well combined. Alternatively, gently heat up the almond and coconut butter until soft. Place in a bowl and mix into a dough with the remaining ingredients.
  5. Using your hands, create 12 small cookie dough balls (33 g/ 1.2 oz per ball). Place them on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper or a non-stick silicon baking mat. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  6. Using your thumb, dent each cookie and shape into a small bowl. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  7. Place in the oven and bake for about 12 minutes or until lightly browned. When done, remove from the oven and let them cool down.
  8. At first, they will be fragile and that's when you need to dent the cookies again in the middle but this time with a teaspoon. Gently dent them without breaking. This way they will be able to hold more filling. The cookies will harden as they chill but they will remain fragile - do not remove them from the baking sheet or they may break. Once completely cool, they are ready for to be decorated.
  9. Top each one with a heaped teaspoon of the chia jam.
    Note: I kept the cookies on the silicon mat until they were fully decorated, and then gently placed them one by one in a large plate. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  10. In a bowl, mix the mascarpone, vanilla and pumpkin pie spice mix. Optionally, add sweetener. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  11. Spoon the mascarpone filling in a piping bag and fill each cookie with about a tablespoon. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  12. Using the other side of a teaspoon, create a small dent in the middle of the filling. Add about ¼ teaspoon of the pumpkin seed butter to create the "iris". Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  13. Finally, top with a small piece of dark tahini to create the "pupil". Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies
  14. The cookies are ready to be served. You can keep them in the fridge for up to 5 days. Once stored, the chia jam may slightly bleed into the mascarpone filling which enhances the spooky effect! Undecorated cookies can be stored in an airtight container for up to a week or frozen for up to 3 months. Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies Happy Halloween! Spooky Eyeball Keto Cookies

Do you like this recipe? Share it with your friends! 

Leave a comment

Note: Any links to products or affiliate links will not be approved.

B I U “ ”
  • Comment
  • Preview

Please, note that I do not offer personalised advice. For personalised advice you can contact one of our experts.

As Featured On

As Featured